Skip to content

[00] Compare

Subset Sizes vs Regenerate Thumbnails

Last reviewed

Pick Subset Sizes if you want uploads to make only the sizes you use, and old posts to pick up a changed size without a regenerate run. Pick Regenerate Thumbnails if you'd rather keep WordPress making every size at upload and rebuild them from a screen in wp-admin when a size or theme changes. It needs no server rule and runs on much older versions of PHP.

Feature by feature

Subset Sizes and Regenerate Thumbnails compared, with which one is ahead on each row
CriterionSubset SizesFreeRegenerate ThumbnailsFree Source 1Ahead
When sizes are madeThe first time a page asks for one, or at upload for the sizes you tickAt upload, as WordPress does, and again each time you regenerate Source 2Subset Sizes
After a size or theme changeOld posts get the new size the next time they're shownRegenerate the images that need the new size Source 2Subset Sizes
Disk usageWith lazy sizes on, a size no page asks for is never writtenEvery registered size for each image it regenerates. It can delete old, unused sizes Source 2Subset Sizes
Regenerating from wp-adminNo regenerate screen. Use the WP-CLI generate command, or Pro's pre-warmUnder Tools, from the Media Library list view and on the edit attachment screen Source 2Regenerate Thumbnails
WP-CLIIts own commands to generate missing sizes, clean up orphaned files and show statsNone of its own. The readme recommends WP-CLI's media regenerate command Source 2Subset Sizes
Server setupnginx needs one extra rule. Apache with pretty permalinks needs noneNone. It runs only in the admin area Source 2Regenerate Thumbnails
Minimum versionsWordPress 6.5 and PHP 8.1WordPress 4.7 and PHP 5.2.4 Source 2Regenerate Thumbnails
Track recordVersion 0.5.3Over 1 million active installs, first released in 2008 Source 1Regenerate Thumbnails
PriceFree. Pro is a paid add-onFree Source 1Tie

When to pick Regenerate Thumbnails

Regenerate Thumbnails suits a site where you want every size on disk before anyone visits, and would rather press a button in wp-admin than run a WP-CLI command.

It also suits a host where you can't add a server rule for missing image files, or a server still on a PHP version older than 8.1. It has over a million active installs and was first released in 2008.

Sources

What this page says about Regenerate Thumbnails comes from these pages, checked on 21 October 2026. What it says about Subset Sizes comes from the Subset Sizes page and its documentation.

  1. Regenerate Thumbnails on WordPress.orghttps://wordpress.org/plugins/regenerate-thumbnails/
  2. Regenerate Thumbnails readmehttps://plugins.svn.wordpress.org/regenerate-thumbnails/trunk/readme.txt

All comparisons