Skip to content

[00] Compare

Subset Redirects vs Safe Redirect Manager

Last reviewed

Pick Subset Redirects if you want a 404 log to work from, imports from other plugins with a preview in wp-admin, and thousands of redirects without raising a limit. Pick Safe Redirect Manager if you need regular expressions and wildcards in a free plugin, and want redirects kept as WordPress posts with no settings screen.

Feature by feature

Subset Redirects and Safe Redirect Manager compared, with which one is ahead on each row
CriterionSubset RedirectsFreeSafe Redirect ManagerFree Source 1Ahead
404 logGrouped by URL, bots skipped, no IP addresses, 30 days keptNone. Its readme names 404 logging as a performance risk Source 2Subset Redirects
Regular expressions and wildcardsIn ProFree, with replacements in the target Source 2Safe Redirect Manager
Bulk importCSV with a preview in wp-admin, and from Redirection, Yoast SEO Premium and Rank MathCSV and .htaccess files, from WP-CLI Source 3Subset Redirects
WP-CLIAdd, update, test, import and export redirects, and read the 404 logList, create, delete and import redirects, and rebuild its cache Source 3Tie
Redirects in version controlExport to CSV and import it again, from WP-CLI or wp-adminImport from CSV. No export command is listed Source 3Subset Redirects
Large redirect listsOne indexed lookup per request. Under 1 ms with 5,000 redirects in our test1,000 redirects by default, raised with a filter. Redirects are cached as a transient Source 2Subset Redirects
Status codes301, 302 and 410301 and 302, plus 403, 404 and 410 rules. A filter adds more Source 2Safe Redirect Manager
Minimum WordPress version6.06.9 Source 2Subset Redirects
PriceFree. Pro is a paid add-onFree Source 1Tie

When to pick Safe Redirect Manager

Safe Redirect Manager suits a site that needs regular expression or wildcard redirects without a paid add-on.

It also suits a team that wants redirects stored as an ordinary post type and changed from code through its actions and filters, with no 404 log or settings screen. It's built by 10up, and its readme says major publishing sites use it.

Sources

What this page says about Safe Redirect Manager comes from these pages, checked on 21 October 2026. What it says about Subset Redirects comes from the Subset Redirects page and its documentation.

  1. Safe Redirect Manager on WordPress.orghttps://wordpress.org/plugins/safe-redirect-manager/
  2. Safe Redirect Manager readmehttps://plugins.svn.wordpress.org/safe-redirect-manager/trunk/readme.txt
  3. Safe Redirect Manager on GitHub: CLI commandshttps://github.com/10up/safe-redirect-manager#cli-commands

All comparisons